Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. If you click a link on this page and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Getting a brow pencil to look natural can be tricky when you need to fill sparse areas without making the whole brow look heavy. The Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil tackles that problem with a mechanical teardrop-shaped tip that gives you both a narrow edge and a broader filling surface. A built-in spoolie helps soften the color after application. The main drawback is important, however: Maybelline has discontinued this product, so it makes the most sense only if you specifically want its applicator style and can still find the correct shade from a reliable seller.
Quick Verdict
Rating: 7/10, Recommended with caveats
Best For: You if you prefer a mechanical brow pencil with a wider teardrop tip for quick shaping and filling.
Bottom Line: The narrow edge, broad base, and built-in spoolie make this pencil practical for soft, defined brows without carrying a separate brush. Its biggest drawback is that Maybelline has discontinued it, so availability and seller quality require more attention than they would with a current brow pencil.
Key Specifications
| Specification | Detail |
|---|---|
| Brand | Maybelline New York |
| Product | Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil |
| Product type | Mechanical eyebrow pencil |
| Amazon variant reviewed | 310 Medium Brown, 1 Count |
| Net weight | 0.005 oz |
| Applicator | Teardrop-shaped brow tip |
| Blending tool | Built-in fluffy spoolie brush |
| Official shades listed | Blonde, Soft Brown, Medium Brown, Deep Brown |
| Design | Narrow edge for defining, broader base for filling |
| Sharpening | Not required because the pencil is mechanical |
| Manufacturer status | Discontinued |
| Best use | Shaping brows, filling sparse areas, and creating a soft defined finish |
Power your essentials anywhere with a 999Wh pure sine wave power station delivering up to 1000W continuous with 2000W surge. It supports fast charging via USB-C PD 60W and USB-A QC 18W, plus simultaneous output for multiple devices through AC, USB, wireless, and car/DC ports. Recharge using AC, car, or solar with a built-in MPPT controller and dual cooling fans, while the upgraded battery management system protects against surges, short circuits, and overheating.
Brow Stylist Definer Eyebrow Pencil: Ultra fine self sharpening mechanical brow pencil draws on tiny brow hairs to fill in sparse areas or gaps and spoolie brush styles and defines brow shape
Triangular tip for hair-like strokes and fool-proof brows
What Is the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil?
The Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer is a dual-ended mechanical brow pencil from Maybelline. One end holds the color in a teardrop-shaped applicator, while the opposite end has a spoolie brush for grooming and blending.
The teardrop shape is the main reason to choose this pencil over a very thin micro-definer. You can use its narrow end around the brow outline and tail, then turn to the wider base when you need to cover a larger sparse area. That combination favors quick shaping and filling rather than extremely fine individual strokes.
The exact Amazon ASIN reviewed here is associated with the 310 Medium Brown version. Maybelline also lists Blonde, Soft Brown, and Deep Brown among the original shades, but the entire Total Temptation brow pencil line is now listed as discontinued by the manufacturer.
Who Should Buy It?
Best For
- You want a wider teardrop applicator that can define and fill with the same tip.
- You prefer a soft, natural-looking brow instead of an extremely sharp micro-pencil finish.
- You like having a spoolie built into the same tool for quick blending and grooming.
Skip If
- You want a current product with dependable ongoing retail availability.
- You need an ultra-fine tip for very small, individual hair-like strokes.
- You specifically need a formula marketed as waterproof or vegan.
Before You Buy: Maybelline lists the Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil as discontinued. Check the exact shade, seller, package condition, and current product details before purchasing, especially when buying remaining stock from third-party sellers.
Teardrop Tip for Shaping and Filling
The teardrop tip is the defining feature of this brow pencil. Maybelline designed the narrow end for outlining and more controlled work around the arch and tail. The broader base covers more surface area when you need to fill the center of the brow.
This makes the pencil easier to use when speed matters. Instead of repeatedly drawing with a tiny point across a larger sparse patch, you can rotate the applicator and use the wider part. You can then return to the narrow edge where a cleaner boundary is needed.
The tradeoff is precision. A teardrop point is not the same as an ultra-slim micro pencil. If your main goal is drawing many very fine strokes into a nearly bare brow, a thinner current-generation brow pencil may give you more control.
Blending and Grooming With the Spoolie Brush
The built-in fluffy spoolie is more than an extra attachment. It lets you distribute color through the brow and soften areas where the pencil looks too concentrated.
After applying color, brush the hairs upward and slightly outward in their natural direction. This can break up obvious pencil lines and help the filled sections look less flat. If one area becomes too dark, brushing through it before adding more product can reduce the need to erase and start again.
Pro Tip: Build the brow in light layers. Add a few strokes, brush through them with the spoolie, and only then decide whether you need more color. This gives you better control than filling the entire brow heavily in one pass.
How to Use the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil
Maybelline’s application method uses different parts of the teardrop tip for different sections of your brow. You can follow the same basic sequence whenever you want a softly defined finish.
- Define the shape: Use the narrow end of the teardrop tip to trace the brow where extra definition is needed.
- Fill from the inner brow toward the arch: Turn to the broader base of the tip to cover sparse areas more efficiently.
- Finish the tail: Switch back to the narrow end for the outer section where a smaller point gives you better control.
- Blend and groom: Brush through the finished brow with the spoolie to distribute the color and soften visible pencil marks.
Use light pressure, especially near the inner brow. A softer application there usually looks more natural than creating the same intensity from the inner corner all the way to the tail.
How It Performs in Real Use
For Filling Sparse Areas
The wider section of the teardrop tip makes sense when your brow has noticeable gaps rather than just one or two missing hairs. You can cover the area faster, then brush through the color so it does not sit as one solid patch.
For Quick Everyday Makeup
The two-ended format reduces the number of tools you need. You can shape, fill, groom, and soften with one pencil. That is useful when you want a basic brow routine without carrying a separate spoolie.
For Fine Detail Work
The narrow edge can create more controlled marks than the broad side, but it is still a teardrop tip rather than a dedicated micro point. If very fine stroke-by-stroke detail is your priority, this is where a 1.5 mm-style brow pencil has an advantage.
For Long Days or Humid Conditions
The original article made strong wear and smudging claims, but Maybelline’s current archived product information does not market Total Temptation as waterproof. Avoid assuming it will perform like a modern waterproof brow pen or long-wear sealing gel. If wear resistance is a major buying requirement, choose a product with a clear manufacturer claim for that use.
Material Safety and Formula Notes
Maybelline’s ingredient list for Total Temptation includes synthetic Japan wax, stearic acid, hydrogenated soybean oil, hydrogenated vegetable oil, beeswax, carnauba wax, tocopherol, and colorants that may include iron oxides and titanium dioxide.
The presence of beeswax means this formula should not be treated as vegan under the usual definition of a vegan cosmetic. That is worth knowing if avoiding animal-derived ingredients is part of your buying criteria.
The official product page also does not describe this pencil as waterproof. Because cosmetic formulas and sensitivities differ from person to person, follow the package directions, avoid using a damaged or contaminated product, and stop using it if you develop irritation around the application area.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Teardrop tip gives you a narrow edge and a broader filling surface.
- Mechanical design does not require traditional sharpening.
- Built-in spoolie handles grooming and blending in the same tool.
- Simple application method works well for soft everyday brow definition.
- Medium Brown and several other classic brow shades were produced.
Cons
- The product has been discontinued, so availability may be inconsistent.
- The teardrop design is less precise than an ultra-slim tip for very fine strokes.
- The formula contains beeswax and is not presented by Maybelline as waterproof.
Is It Worth the Price?
The Total Temptation pencil can still offer reasonable value when you specifically want its teardrop tip and can find the correct shade at a sensible price. Its built-in spoolie and mechanical format give you the core tools needed for a straightforward everyday brow routine.
Its discontinued status changes the value equation. Remaining stock can come from different sellers, and there is little reason to pay a large premium simply because the pencil is harder to find. A current Maybelline brow product is likely the better value if you care more about easy replacement, a wider shade selection, or clearly stated long-wear performance.
How It Compares to Alternatives
The current Maybelline Brow Ultra Slim Micro-Definer Pencil is a better comparison if you want finer detail. It uses a 1.5 mm tip, includes a spoolie, and is designed for small hair-like strokes. Maybelline also currently markets it with fade-, smudge-, water-, sweat-, and transfer-resistance claims, making it a stronger choice when long wear is important.
The Maybelline Build-A-Brow 2-in-1 Brow Pen and Sealing Gel serves a different buyer. Its pen creates thin brow-like marks, while the clear gel sets the hairs. Maybelline markets that product as waterproof with up to 24-hour wear. Total Temptation makes more sense only if you prefer a traditional wax-based mechanical pencil and the broader teardrop applicator.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil discontinued?
Yes. Maybelline’s official product page currently labels Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil as discontinued. You may still find remaining inventory through some sellers, but ongoing availability should not be assumed.
Is the Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer waterproof?
Maybelline’s official information for this discontinued pencil does not market it as waterproof. If waterproof wear is essential for you, compare it with a current brow product that carries an explicit waterproof claim.
Does the eyebrow pencil need sharpening?
No traditional pencil sharpener is required because Total Temptation is a mechanical brow pencil. The product advances from its casing rather than using a sharpenable wooden body.
How should you use the teardrop-shaped tip?
Use the narrow end to define the brow and work around the tail. Turn to the broader base when filling from the inner brow toward the arch, then finish by brushing through the color with the spoolie.
Which shade is associated with Amazon ASIN B074VGYK4X?
The Amazon listing for ASIN B074VGYK4X identifies the product as Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil in 310 Medium Brown, 1 Count. Check the seller’s current listing details before ordering because the product is discontinued.
Is the Maybelline Total Temptation brow pencil vegan?
The published ingredient list includes beeswax. Because beeswax is animal-derived, you should not treat this formula as vegan if avoiding animal-derived cosmetic ingredients matters to you.
Is the teardrop tip good for very fine brow strokes?
The narrow edge can give you controlled definition, but the applicator is wider than a dedicated micro pencil. If you mainly want very thin individual strokes, a 1.5 mm micro-definer is a better match.
Does Total Temptation include a spoolie brush?
Yes. A fluffy spoolie is built into the opposite end of the pencil. Use it after filling your brows to soften concentrated color, groom the hairs, and create a more natural finish.
The Bottom Line
The Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil is still appealing if you like a teardrop tip that can switch between outlining and faster filling, plus a built-in spoolie for blending. It is less attractive if you want micro-level precision, a vegan formula, an explicit waterproof claim, or a product you can reliably replace in the future because Maybelline has discontinued it.
Ready to Buy?
Check the current seller, shade, availability, and product details before you decide.
