Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. If you click a link on this page and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
A good lip gloss should add shine without making your lips feel heavy or overly sticky. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss is designed for that job, with a glossy, non-sticky formula that can be worn alone or layered over other lip products. The Amazon link in this review points specifically to Sugar Glass, a clear Butter Gloss shade, while NYX also sells many tinted shades across the range. This review explains what you get, how the formula behaves in everyday use, and the main reasons you may want to buy it or skip it.
Quick Verdict
Rating: 8.5/10
Best For: Shoppers who want an affordable-feeling, high-shine gloss with a non-sticky texture and easy layering.
Bottom Line: NYX Butter Gloss is easy to wear and gives you flexible sheer-to-medium shine across a broad shade range. The main tradeoffs are that it transfers like a typical gloss, contains fragrance, and is not vegan.
| Specification | Detail |
|---|---|
| Brand | NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP |
| Product | Butter Gloss Non-Sticky Lip Gloss |
| Linked Amazon variant | Sugar Glass, Clear |
| Amazon ASIN | B09SP2XHKT |
| Product type | High-shine lip gloss |
| Coverage | Sheer to medium across the Butter Gloss range |
| Texture | Non-sticky, glossy formula |
| Applicator | Soft wand applicator |
| How to wear | Alone, over lip liner, or over lipstick |
| Scent | Sweet scented |
| Vegan | No |
| Cruelty-free | Yes |
| Transfer-resistant | No, NYX states the gloss transfers |
| Plumping formula | No |
Before You Buy: The Amazon link in this article is for Sugar Glass, which is the clear version. If you want a tinted shade such as Angel Food Cake or Tiramisu, confirm the selected shade on the product page before ordering.
What Is NYX Butter Gloss?
NYX Butter Gloss is a high-shine lip gloss line made for shoppers who want a softer, less sticky feel than many traditional glosses. NYX describes the formula as non-sticky and says you can wear it by itself or layer it over lip liner or lipstick.
The linked Sugar Glass variant is clear, so it adds shine without adding a noticeable tint. Elsewhere in the range, NYX offers nudes, pinks, reds, browns, and shimmer options. The brand’s current FAQ says the Butter Gloss family includes 42 shades in total, though the exact shades available from a given retailer can change.
Power your essentials anywhere with a 999Wh pure sine wave power station delivering up to 1000W continuous with 2000W surge. It supports fast charging via USB-C PD 60W and USB-A QC 18W, plus simultaneous output for multiple devices through AC, USB, wireless, and car/DC ports. Recharge using AC, car, or solar with a built-in MPPT controller and dual cooling fans, while the upgraded battery management system protects against surges, short circuits, and overheating.
Butter Gloss: Buttery soft and silky smooth, our decadent Butter Gloss is available in a wide variety of sumptuous shades; Each glossy color delivers sheer to medium coverage that melts onto your lips
Butter Gloss: Buttery soft and silky smooth, our decadent Butter Gloss is available in a wide variety of sumptuous shades; Each glossy color delivers sheer to medium coverage that melts onto your lips
Who Should Buy It?
Best For
- You want glossy shine without a very tacky texture.
- You want a clear topper that can go over liner or lipstick.
- You like having many tinted and shimmer shades to choose from in the same product family.
Skip If
- You need a vegan lip gloss.
- You want a transfer-proof or long-wear liquid lip product.
- You prefer completely fragrance-free lip products.
Texture, Shine, and Coverage
The strongest reason to consider Butter Gloss is its texture. NYX positions it as a non-sticky gloss, and the finish is clearly glossy rather than matte or satin. That makes it useful when you want visible shine without the heavier tack some gloss formulas can have.
Coverage across the Butter Gloss range is sheer to medium. That means your natural lip color can still influence the final result, especially with lighter or more translucent shades. Sugar Glass is the simplest example because it is clear and mainly changes the finish rather than the color.
The gloss is not marketed as transfer-proof. NYX specifically notes that it transfers like other glosses, so you should expect to touch it up after eating, drinking, or wiping your lips. That tradeoff matters if you are comparing it with a stain or a long-wear liquid lipstick.
Shades and Color Options
Butter Gloss is sold in a broad mix of colors, including nude, pink, red, brown, clear, and shimmer shades. NYX currently describes 42 shades across its classic and Bling selections, although individual colors may be temporarily unavailable or may differ by retailer.
Two well-known tinted options are Angel Food Cake, which NYX describes as a lavender mauve, and Tiramisu, which the brand describes as a pinky nude. Those are different buying choices from the linked Sugar Glass variant, which is clear.
Because Butter Gloss has sheer-to-medium coverage, the same shade can look different depending on your natural lip tone and any liner or lipstick underneath it. For the most accurate choice, check the current shade swatch and selected variant before checkout.
Formula, Ingredients, and Lip Comfort
NYX publishes ingredient lists for Butter Gloss, but the exact formula can vary by shade. Current ingredient information for the line includes gloss-building ingredients and waxes, along with fragrance. The brand also states directly that Butter Gloss is not vegan, while describing it as cruelty-free.
If your lips are sensitive to fragrance or certain cosmetic ingredients, read the ingredient list for your exact shade on the package before use. A gloss can feel comfortable for many users and still be a poor match for someone who reacts to a specific ingredient.
Butter Gloss is also not a plumping product. If your main goal is a tingling, volumizing, or plumping effect, you should choose a product made specifically for that purpose rather than expecting it from this formula.
How to Apply NYX Butter Gloss
- Start with clean lips. Remove loose, flaky skin gently so the gloss sits more evenly.
- Use a light layer of balm only if needed. If your lips are dry, apply a small amount and blot excess so the gloss does not slide around.
- Apply with the included wand. Brush the gloss over the top and bottom lip, starting near the center and working outward.
- Add definition with liner. NYX recommends pairing Butter Gloss with lip liner if you want a more defined shape.
- Layer carefully over lipstick. A thin coat is usually enough to add shine without making the lip look overly thick.
- Reapply when needed. Because the formula transfers, refresh it after meals or whenever the shine has worn down.
Pro Tip: For more definition, line your lips first and then apply Butter Gloss from the center outward. This follows NYX’s own recommendation to pair the gloss with a lip pencil.
How It Performs in Real Use
For Everyday Bare-Lip Shine
Sugar Glass works well when you want shine without changing your lip color. A light coat gives a glossy finish, and the non-sticky positioning makes it a practical option for quick everyday makeup.
Over Lip Liner
Butter Gloss can soften the look of a liner while keeping the edges more defined. This is useful if you want a glossy lip but do not want the clear linked shade to look too plain on its own.
Over Lipstick
The gloss can be layered over lipstick to add shine and make a flat finish look more reflective. Use a small amount, since too much gloss can make the color move around and increase transfer.
During Meals and Drinks
This is where the main limitation appears. Butter Gloss transfers, so some product will come off on cups, food, or napkins. It is better suited to shoppers who do not mind reapplication than to anyone who wants an all-day, no-touch-up lip product.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Non-sticky, high-shine finish.
- Sheer-to-medium coverage across the range.
- Can be worn alone or layered over liner and lipstick.
- Broad shade family, including clear, nude, pink, red, brown, and shimmer choices.
- Cruelty-free according to NYX.
Cons
- The gloss transfers and may need reapplication after eating or drinking.
- The formula is not vegan.
- The sweet scent and fragrance may not suit every user.
Is It Worth the Price?
Butter Gloss sits in the budget-friendly part of the lip gloss market and gives you a simple combination of shine, color choice, and layering flexibility. The clearest value comes from the non-sticky feel and the ability to use one gloss on bare lips, with liner, or over lipstick.
The linked Sugar Glass shade is especially straightforward if you already own lip colors you like and only need a clear glossy topper. You may get less value from it if you need vegan ingredients, fragrance-free makeup, or a finish that stays in place through meals without touch-ups.
How It Compares to Alternatives
If you want a glossy product with an oil-based, hydrating positioning and a vegan formula, e.l.f. Glow Reviver Lip Oil is a useful alternative to compare. If you want a more premium gloss with conditioning ingredients and a vegan formula, Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Universal Lip Luminizer is another option.
NYX Butter Gloss makes the most sense when you prefer a classic gloss format, a broad shade family, and a non-sticky high-shine finish without moving into a more premium price tier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which NYX Butter Gloss shade does the Amazon link open?
The linked ASIN B09SP2XHKT is for Sugar Glass, the clear Butter Gloss variant. If you want Angel Food Cake, Tiramisu, or another tinted shade, confirm the selected color before you buy.
Is NYX Butter Gloss sticky?
NYX describes Butter Gloss as a non-sticky high-shine formula. It still has the slip and shine of a gloss, but it is designed to avoid the very tacky feel associated with some traditional formulas.
Is NYX Butter Gloss vegan?
No. NYX’s current Butter Gloss FAQ says the product is not vegan, although the brand describes it as cruelty-free. Check the current ingredient list for your exact shade if ingredient sourcing matters to you.
Does NYX Butter Gloss transfer?
Yes. NYX states that Butter Gloss transfers like other glosses. Expect to reapply after eating, drinking, or wiping your lips if you want to keep the same level of shine.
Is NYX Butter Gloss a plumping gloss?
No. NYX says Butter Gloss is not a plumping product. Its main job is to provide glossy shine and color rather than a plumping effect.
Can you wear Butter Gloss over lipstick or lip liner?
Yes. NYX says you can wear it on bare lips or layer it over other lip products. Lip liner adds definition, while a thin layer over lipstick adds a glossy finish.
How long does NYX Butter Gloss last?
NYX does not position Butter Gloss as transfer-proof, so there is no reason to expect fixed all-day wear. How often you reapply will depend on eating, drinking, talking, and how much product you use.
Is Butter Gloss a good choice for sensitive lips?
The formula contains fragrance, and ingredient lists can vary by shade. If your lips are sensitive, read the label for your exact shade first and stop using the product if you notice irritation.
The Bottom Line
NYX Butter Gloss is a strong pick if you want easy glossy shine, a non-sticky feel, and the option to wear the product alone or over other lip makeup. The linked Sugar Glass shade is best for buyers who want clear shine, while shoppers who need a vegan, fragrance-free, or transfer-proof formula should consider another product.
